Skip to content

Audiophiles

Search
Close this search box.

Meinl vs Zildjian Cymbals

When it comes to drumming, the cymbals are just as important as the drums themselves. They add to the overall sound and atmosphere of the music, and can often make or break a performance. Two of the biggest names in cymbals are Meinl and Zildjian. Both brands have been around for decades, and have gained a reputation for producing high-quality cymbals. However, when it comes to choosing between the two, which one is the better option? In this article, we’ll compare Meinl and Zildjian cymbals to help you make an informed decision.

Materials and Construction
The materials used in cymbal production play a big role in determining the sound and durability of the cymbals. Meinl cymbals are made of B20 bronze, which is a mix of 80% copper and 20% tin. B20 bronze is known for its bright and cutting sound, as well as its durability. On the other hand, Zildjian cymbals are made of a secret alloy that they call Zildjian Bronze. Zildjian Bronze is known for its warm and musical tone, and is favored by many professional drummers.

When it comes to construction, both Meinl and Zildjian take great care to ensure that their cymbals are of the highest quality. Meinl cymbals are hand-hammered and lathed, which results in a cymbal with a complex and dynamic sound. Zildjian cymbals are also hand-hammered, and they use a proprietary casting process that they call the “Sequential Hammering System.” This process results in a cymbal with a balanced and consistent sound.

Sound Quality
The sound quality of a cymbal is one of the most important factors to consider when choosing between Meinl and Zildjian. Meinl cymbals are known for their bright and cutting sound, which makes them well suited for styles of music that require a lot of attack and clarity. Zildjian cymbals are known for their warm and musical tone, which makes them well suited for styles of music that require a more subtle and nuanced sound.

One of the key differences between Meinl and Zildjian cymbals is the way that they are voiced. Meinl cymbals are voiced to be bright and cutting, while Zildjian cymbals are voiced to be warm and musical. This difference in voicing means that Meinl cymbals may not be the best choice for styles of music that require a more nuanced sound, while Zildjian cymbals may not be the best choice for styles of music that require a lot of attack and clarity.

Durability
Both Meinl and Zildjian cymbals are made to be durable, and both are known for their long-lasting sound. However, there are some differences between the two that may impact their durability. Meinl cymbals are made of B20 bronze, which is a mix of 80% copper and 20% tin. This mix of materials results in a cymbal that is resistant to cracks and other types of damage. Zildjian cymbals, on the other hand, are made of a secret alloy that they call Zildjian Bronze. While Zildjian Bronze is known for its warm and musical tone, it may not be as durable as B20 bronze.

In addition to the differences in materials, the construction methods used by Meinl and Zildjian can also impact the durability of the cymbals. Meinl cymbals are hand-hammered and lathed, which gives them a complex and dynamic sound. This construction method can also result in a cymbal that is more vulnerable to damage over time. Zildjian cymbals, on the other hand, are hand-hammered using the Sequential Hammering System, which results in a cymbal that is more balanced and consistent in sound. This construction method can also result in a cymbal that is more durable over time.

Price
When it comes to price, both Meinl and Zildjian cymbals are at the high end of the market. Meinl cymbals are generally more affordable than Zildjian cymbals, but the difference in price is not significant. However, it’s worth noting that Meinl offers a wider range of cymbals at different price points, so you may be able to find a Meinl cymbal that fits your budget more easily. Zildjian cymbals, on the other hand, are generally more expensive, but the premium price is often justified by the quality of the cymbals.

Conclusion
In conclusion, both Meinl and Zildjian cymbals are excellent options for drummers who are looking for high-quality cymbals. The materials used, construction methods, and sound quality are all important factors to consider when choosing between the two. Meinl cymbals are made of B20 bronze and are known for their bright and cutting sound, while Zildjian cymbals are made of Zildjian Bronze and are known for their warm and musical tone. Meinl cymbals are generally more affordable than Zildjian cymbals, but both brands offer high-quality cymbals at a premium price. Ultimately, the choice between Meinl and Zildjian cymbals will come down to your personal preferences and the type of music that you play.

FAQ

What are Meinl cymbals made of?
Meinl cymbals are made of B20 bronze, which is a high-quality alloy that contains 20% tin, 80% copper, and trace amounts of silver.

What are Zildjian cymbals made of?
Zildjian cymbals are made of Zildjian Bronze, which is a proprietary alloy that contains copper, tin, and other metals. The exact composition of Zildjian Bronze is a closely guarded secret.

Are Meinl cymbals good for heavy metal music?
Yes, Meinl cymbals are good for heavy metal music. Meinl offers a range of cymbals with bright and cutting sounds that are well-suited for heavy metal and other aggressive styles of music.

Are Zildjian cymbals good for jazz music?
Yes, Zildjian cymbals are good for jazz music. Zildjian offers a range of cymbals with warm and musical sounds that are well-suited for jazz and other styles of music that require a more nuanced and delicate touch.

Are Meinl cymbals cheaper than Zildjian cymbals?
Yes, Meinl cymbals are generally more affordable than Zildjian cymbals, but the difference in price is not significant. Both Meinl and Zildjian offer high-quality cymbals at a premium price.

Can I use Meinl cymbals with Zildjian cymbals?
Yes, you can use Meinl cymbals with Zildjian cymbals. The sound quality and tonal characteristics of each brand are different, but you can use cymbals from different brands in the same drum set.