If you consider yourself to be an audiophile, you might be asking why a soundbar is preferable to a set of high-quality bookshelf speakers (which would sound better). The answer is that a soundbar might be preferable depending on the size of your space and your personal preferences. First-time home theater enthusiasts typically have smaller spaces, and the main reason they don’t choose a good set of bookshelf speakers is that they don’t want to deal with properly situating them. A soundbar takes care of everything for you, so you don’t need to bother about it.
However, you should be aware that soundbars have a few drawbacks. In some cases, they won’t perform as well as a good set of bookshelf speakers in terms of sound quality, and they can easily take up more room and use more electricity. Bookshelf speakers can be a better choice for you if space is an issue. In addition, soundbars can be trickier to install properly than bookshelf speakers. With a soundbar, you might need a specialized receiver or amp, whereas you might connect your bookshelf speakers to an existing receiver.
The Soundbar, on the other hand, might be the best option if you’re seeking for a quick and simple fix that will be functional right out of the box. Many excellent soundbars produce wonderful sound. A soundbar is also a good option if you want a wireless speaker that is simple to move about. You can immediately take one and move it to another room or, if you like, take it outside. If you have a little room, this can be the best option.
Table of Contents
What is a Bookshelf Speaker?
Small, independent speakers called bookshelf speakers typically don’t have a subwoofer. They are often a two-way speaker system, blasting the tweeter and woofer out the front, toward you. On a shelf or side table, facing you, bookshelf speakers are often set up. They can also be mounted on the wall behind your TV or put on a floor stand. A 2-way speaker set is what you typically see on bookshelves. Typically, a tweeter and a woofer are part of this. The woofer is in the bottom, and the tweeter is at the top. A passive radiator (or two) may also be present to aid bass response.
Although they are typically more expensive than soundbars, bookshelf speakers have higher sound quality. They will sound significantly better since they have a wider frequency response range, greater dynamic range, and typically larger drivers and tweeters. Additionally, bookshelf speakers are more portable and frequently have a better aesthetic than the long, thin Soundbar.
If you want a better audio system and an accurate surround sound experience, bookshelf speakers are a terrific option. They are an excellent option if you want to test something more powerful or if you want to improve your home theater system.
Bookshelf Speakers Sound Quality
Your speakers’ technology will determine the caliber of the sound they produce. 2-way systems frequently contain passive radiators. They are merely extended cylinders that aid in bass response. Since passive radiators lack a magnet and any moving parts, they are unable to independently produce sound. They tremble in response to the woofer’s sound (i.e. when you play low frequencies, the passive radiator will start vibrating). When a speaker enclosure is empty or there is no other method to produce bass response from a 2-way speaker system, passive radiators are occasionally used.
Similar to passive radiators, active radiators vibrate in reaction to the woofer’s sound with the use of electromagnets. As a result, active radiators will vibrate even if the amplifier is not receiving any input signal. They may appear noisier than passive radiators as a result. Two-way speaker systems are the only ones that use active radiators. They do not occur frequently.
Active radiators are typically used when a speaker system is attempting to get bass response from a 2-way system and cannot do so without the addition of active radiators. A few 3-way speaker systems have three drivers that are all active radiators (i.e. tweeter, midrange and woofer). However, the majority of three-way speaker systems use passive radiators for every driver.
What is a Soundbar?
A long, thin speaker called a soundbar is placed below or next to your TV. It normally features a few tweeters up top and one main driver at the bottom. Additionally, it will contain a subwoofer, making it a soundbar, to provide your bass frequencies. If you install it above or below your TV, it will resemble a bookshelf speaker. However, a single soundbar may accomplish the same task with considerably less trouble and expense than installing several speakers throughout your room and running the wiring to link them.
Soundbases are another name for soundbars. With the driver facing up and the tweeters facing you, they often feature a rectangular shell that sits right below the TV. For true wireless surround sound, some soundbars even incorporate wireless subwoofers.
Soundbars are affordable, simple to install, and typically come with a remote control for changing the bass and volume (and sometimes treble). Additionally, they typically include a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) for decoding and processing audio signals. Later, more on DAC.
If you go with a renowned brand and the Soundbar has a decent-sized driver, the sound quality can be outstanding. If you don’t want to invest the money or bother on a complete surround sound system, soundbars are a great substitute. However, some people dislike their size or heft, particularly if they have limited room beneath their TV.
Soundbars Sound Quality
The majority of soundbars have a two-way system, with one driver handling the highs and another handling the lows. The tweeters are typically on top and facing your direction. Typically, the woofers are on the bottom and facing downward (like most bookshelf speakers).
Some soundbars offer three-way systems that include passive radiators, woofers, and tweeters. Typically, these soundbars will also have a subwoofer. The brand and model of Soundbar you purchase will determine the sound quality. Some companies are widely known for the caliber of their audio. Some manufacturers also integrate a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) into each speaker channel.
This enables them to process audio internally rather than relying on your TV or receiver to do it entirely, resulting in a few dB higher audio quality. If you want to purchase a soundbar, be sure to review its specifications beforehand. You’ll be aware of the audio quality you’re receiving for your hard-earned money in this manner.
Soundbar vs Bookshelf Speakers: Which Is Better?
Although bookshelf speakers are more difficult to set up and offer higher sound quality than soundbars, they are also much more expensive. They are not the best option for someone looking for a straightforward setup that is suitable for both music and movies. In particular, if you set them up by yourself, soundbars are more simpler to set up than bookshelf speakers.
Consider acquiring a soundbar instead if you have trouble setting up your bookshelf setup. But bookshelf speakers can be a better choice for you if you’re ready to invest some time and money in your setup!